Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Post Mortem of a Project in Italy

I am continuing the sequel from my discussion post to the blog. For those who have not read it I have re-posted it again.

I was preparing a training course for a rollout of a new application to improve the supply chain management programme especially on the logistic side as deliveries were always delayed causing customers to be discouraged. The stakeholders were the executive director and the managers of the sourcing office in Florence, the project manager was someone from San Bruno, CA and the instructional designer was from Hongkong and I was the instructor/facilitator. As Allen & Hardin (2008) state that preparing the different phases of a project requires time. I would like to add that the final project is an evolution of a scaffold process built on hours, days and weeks up to months of preparation.

The project was proposed to rollout after 6 – 8 months of preparation. I was part of the every process since I was handling the logistic department in particular in the IT aspect of it. During this period, I struggled to communicate with the stakeholders because they wanted the end product without looking into the process. The Project Manager had scheduled every aspect of the project but did not include the time difference amongst us not to mention time needed for each aspect to be organised. Our instructional designer did not understand the culture of the people to whom I was going to deliver the training – they were Italians! Two weeks before the actual rollout, I had to call a conference call for everyone to meet after I had sent an extensive email explaining how entangled various aspects had become. As a facilitator, I no longer understood what I was going to deliver.

This was a project that needed a good and efficient project manager. If I had the opportunity to manage this project, I would have considered the timeline and check if all the deliverables would have been met. Also the staffing was essential for the project to succeed. The time differences between its members almost led the coordination into a very tight position. I really would not know how to solve this aspect as the staff selected was highly qualified. Meeting up was one of the greatest frustrations in this project. One way or the other someone had to stay awake in the wee hours of the morning.
If I had a magic wand, I would have flown everyone into Italy for a week or two so we could discuss issues properly without obstacles of time and space. The stakeholders who have been more included in the discussion and not during decision making alone. In this way, they see the process and understand what it means to plan a new application that will correct the previous problems causing the delay of deliveries into the retail stores. The new application rolled out a year later due to various issues.

Having said this, I immensely enjoyed the discussions and the exchange of ideas from people of different cultures and walks of life. It was extremely enriching to see other points of views and consider them in my training. This gave me a possibility to look into other systems and consider what is valid for my office. Yes, it was exhausting but however you put it, the learning experience was the best part of it.

6 comments:

  1. WoW Koulalo great example for the topic. Cultural diversity within a design project hasn't been addressed to the extent that it probably should be. You mention wanting to a magic wand to bring them all together. What would be your suggestion if you had another situation come up like this and knew ahead of time?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Darla,
    I would really organise things differently. I would do a feasibility study and really visit the sourcing offices so I could have a "real feel" of what is happening.

    It would have been so different. Also, technology has improved by then. Internet connections are faster so this will be a helpful tool in organising a project from a distance.

    Malu

    ReplyDelete
  3. Malu,

    You mentioned that if you'd been the project manager you would have had project personnel meet face-to-face (you are right - current communicative technology would have made this a lot easier), but, would you suggest that the project manager make initial personal contact with stakeholders from other sites, at first?

    I guess what I am asking is if there is any room in major projects for a visit from the PM anymore? I think personal contact, of some kind, establishes buy-in. Perhaps it doesn't, I have never been in that situation.

    I hope your school experience is going well.

    Lisa

    ReplyDelete
  4. Malu, Darla, Lisa,
    It's quite remarkable to me how we all agree on the importance of meeting in person. I would like to commend Malu also, in particular for the meeting's purpose of communicating together in a relaxed way so as to facilitate a natural scoping process of sorts, for choosing Italy as the location.

    In my experience, there is no better place than in Italy, where custom supports open, relaxed communication around the leisurely, civilized service of some of the finest food and drink imaginable. If I were doing business, I'd want to do it in Italy.

    To your next project: Salut!

    Ted

    ReplyDelete
  5. Maula,

    It was great to read an actually project that involved some of the issues that could be common in a project that anyone could face including time issues, communication issues and cultural diversity issues. With the advances that are taking place in technology, we can now see some of our way through communication issues when it comes to distance between team members.

    ReplyDelete
  6. To everyone,

    Yes, notwithstanding the technology and the numerous possibility to communicate synchronously I still believe that there is no better way than face-to-face.

    I am currently in Istanbul giving a workshop but still managing the early childhood project in Erbil. My counterpart is an excellent English speaker but we still have miscommunication over skype calls. It is amazing what physical presence can do to alleviate a lot of that angst caused by space and distance.

    Oh Ted, we could all meet up in Italy for our graduation... I know of a castle we can rent for a descent price....

    I wish we would all make it for graduation... that would be a great culminating event for a huge project like MS in Instructional Design and Technology. Don't you think so?

    Malu

    ReplyDelete